Forty Acres & A Mule



Following on from last night's post, I was musing over exactly what nationalised land could look like in practice, assuming a blank canvas with no Taliban-esque dissolution-of-the-monasteries style of wanton destruction or restitutional compensation to either fork out or ignore altogether. These questions remain unasked for the simple fact that land is still, simply, owned. How does a government address this simple conundrum: who gets to build and live/do business where and by whose say-so? The tacit understanding with regards to land ownership - despite historical facts to the absolute contrary - is that certain individuals, families and institutions have historical rights to such ownership: in the UK that starts with the Church and the Monarchy, who over the centuries, through force both physical and spiritual, imposed a web of private land ownership by deed of gift for favours rendered; a concept familiar in more modern times as racketeering and protection, cf the Cosa Nostra, Camorra and most extreme governments, Right or Left, in modern times.

What is the alternative? How would a modern 'commons' work? It's an extraordinarily complex idea to get the modern mind around, as the status quo has been around for most of human history, and no plausible alternative has ever been proffered outside of utopian fiction: indeed the word utopian itself has its origin in the Greek for literally 'nowhere' or no-place; a kind of place that might simply be out of reach. But, even given the tribal instincts of the human race, we still have managed to agree to rules, make laws and form the machinery of governments, armies and economies - despite our barbaric leanings - by some measure of common assent. Surely the next step is to admit our previous failures to address inequality and the absolute shortcomings of a rentier economy and try and invent - invention being the unique jewel in the human crown - another way? 

'Forty acres and a mule' is a phrase deriving from a reneged-upon American Civil War order that was supposed to allot land - and later a mule - to freed African American families, who thought that they would own the land they had worked as slaves under their newly-granted emancipation. Of course, as always, the gift was decidedly Greek in nature and no such freedoms were granted. If elected governments of whatever stripe - and we can only turn to democracies with free and fair elections for relevant example in this - continue to treat their citizens in the abstracted economic manner as units of production and consumption, entitled only to being imposed upon rather than having basic human rights as actors in the economy, then nothing is likely to change: property will remain in the hands of the few and the rest of us will have to maintain our station in society as unwitting agents of the rentier class, however far up the food chain we actually believe ourselves to be.

I caught a fragment of a documentary Jane was watching this evening about an old Caribbean gentleman living in a shack on a beach who would not sell his small plot of beach to a multinational [hotel?] chain at any price, despite their offering him astronomical sums for his few square feet of humble home and beach. The sub-text was that they didn't want people of colour living near their new 'enterprise' aimed at wealthy white tourists. As far as he was concerned his life was sufficient and his home sacred to him: he had no need of a fortune in cash and so demurred politely and carried on in his own way. A small stand such as this proves the durability of our spirit as ordinary humans: we can fight back against the tide, and it would seem that now are the times in which we need to stick two fingers up to the status quo and invent, at last, a true third way, returning to common ownership of common, necessary shared resources. Shelter, warmth and food should not be commodities for sale in some arbitrary and abstract marketplace. Forty acres and a mule might be a metaphor in this context, but I think you might get what I mean...

Comments

  1. Revolution mate this system is SO fucked that it can NOT be fixed!
    ATB
    Joe

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Revolutions invariably result either in autocracy or oligarchy, unfortunately...

      Delete

Post a Comment

Followers